Creative undecidability

· 10 min read

human rolethought experimentspersonal

Who put the straps in our cosmic boots?

As scientific developments keep accelerating in the age of AI, with baffling results nobody could have imagined a short while ago1, we have also entered an era of simulating real worlds. An example of this starts with the complete wiring diagram of a fruit fly brain, mapped2 and turned into a simulation3. Perhaps the model isn’t perfect, but effectively it is a full set of fruit fly neural connections in silico, ready for simulation. When a map of the whole male fly nervous system came out this September4, people immediately made projects with these brains5, ranging from some kind of sick torture chamber game for fruit flies6 to the fly trading cryptocurrencies.

Another line of work generates worlds themselves: models generating a continuous stream of pictures of a given scene, as if you were living in the world. On 17 October, the AI lab Odyssey put the simulated fly brain inside such a world model and let it fly7. The fly navigates in a world generated by an AI: it sees images, its neurons process these images, and the fly changes direction based on that processing. Depending on the direction it turns, the AI generates a new image, resulting in a simulated fruit fly, flying in a simulated world.

Now, what does any of this have to do with anything? This is not a post about AI for once, but in fact a post about religion. I know that’s not everyone’s cup of tea, so if you don’t care, feel free to skip. Due to the aforementioned projects, especially the ones about real-world beings simulated in silico, I feel the case for simulation theory has risen in popularity. If you don’t know, simulation theory is simply the belief that we live in a simulation. Nick Bostrom noted already back in 2003 that “in some ways, the posthumans running a simulation are like gods in relation to the people inhabiting the simulation”8. So, people have been thinking about religion, at least subconsciously, by thinking about the possibility that we are also a simulation. Due to the recent developments, all of us are also thinking about the purpose of our life, if we don’t have a job, or the purpose of our existence, if we’re not the rulers of the world. I think it’s a very fruitful time to talk about religion.

Back to basics

I’ve always pondered about the logical conclusions one arrives at by walking through the arguments about God’s existence. Simplified, I can’t see why people don’t more actively believe in the possibility of undecidability.9

Let me explain how I would arrive at this: On one hand, let’s first assume there is a creator, whichever you prefer it to be; in the inclusive sense of the word, some kind of God. They’re probably not going to show themselves to us, so most likely we will never get to know. But let’s assume they do, so that we would know for sure that God exists. What would that solve, really? The immediate question obviously is who created God? Some people say that God just exists: God is the first being, the first mover (the classical version, from Aristotle’s unmoved mover to Aquinas, is that God is not the kind of being that needs a cause at all), and after that, God created us. I believe many believers don’t want to assume their God to have been created, but if this was the case, the question would have just moved one level up.

Well, what if God was not created? That really solves nothing, at least in my books: anyone who argues like this is willing to accept the fact that there can be something that exists without a creator. Why couldn’t that something then be this universe, and mankind with it10? Why couldn’t we be the first instance of something, the universe created into an empty vacuum? Why do we need something to create us, and for that something to be the first instance? Such a “level-up argument”, sweeping the problem under the rug, never made sense to me.

On the other hand, atheists claim that God doesn’t exist. Well, that’s great as well, but what does it imply? It means that we came out of nowhere and we are the first beings, and we cannot ever know this for sure, because we’ll keep searching for God. I’d consider it likely, that also in the future, there is some kind of belief in a creator, with religion taking new forms as society progresses (simulation theory being a prominent example). Most likely someone will always be searching, and if God doesn’t exist, we probably can never know it for certain. We can only believe strongly that God doesn’t exist, but since there would be no trace of a God who isn’t there, we would never know. You can make probabilistic arguments, as many already make against classical religions: “this and this God doesn’t exist, because this and this text said something would happen and it didn’t”. That clearly doesn’t rule out the existence of an arbitrarily constructed God.11

Something out of nothing?

Now, there is in principle a way out of these options: we could keep moving levels up, accepting that God was created: we have a God, that was created by a higher level God, resulting in a sequence of indefinite length of higher level creators. This is partially already realized, by us creating simulations inside of which people have created further simulations12, and we have put a simulated being into a simulated world, so it’s not that far-fetched. Such a chain of creators could be finite or infinite, in various ways.

If the sequence is finite, we again end with a first being, which might as well just be us. The other case of an infinite sequence of gods seems like an absurd statement, but sadly at this moment I am not able to put into words my intuitive feeling of the impossibility. Such infinite sequences have been alluded to in sci-fi series like Rick and Morty, where you live in recursive simulations. In principle there’s nothing denying that, but it is hard to conceive how such an infinite tower would have made it into existence.

However, there is (at least) one conceivable way of having an infinite tower: combine the properties of finite and infinite sequences, forming a loop. We have a finite number of creators, still forming an infinite sequence. Perhaps one could bootstrap into existence a series of gods that would have created each other, “upholding the chain” and generating something out of nothing, which is one of the fundamental questions about existence itself13.

From a physicist’s perspective, such a “God bootstrap” seems redundant, since physics already has its own version. If we say that the universe was created from some quantum fluctuation of the vacuum14, that of course doesn’t solve the problem of what the surrounding emptiness is. But once there’s a hot universe with the laws we know, we can have sphaleron processes and, with some physics we haven’t found yet, a baryon asymmetry. We don’t know what really happened, but in principle physics already provides candidate mechanisms, not needing a God bootstrap. If we wanted to do God bootstrapping, we would have to resolve a question: who put the straps in our cosmic boots?

Axiom on, axiom off

In mathematics there’s the concept of undecidability, or more precisely independence: some statements can be neither proved nor disproved from the axioms, so you can add either the statement or its opposite as a new axiom, and nothing breaks. The classic example is Euclid’s parallel postulate: Put it on, and you get the flat geometry of primary school. Put its negation on instead, and you get the hyperbolic geometry, satisfying all the other axioms just as well. That’s a completely different answer to a question that asks true or false: it says that the question itself cannot be settled in this system.

So, what if the question of God’s existence and of creation actually ends up in “creative undecidability” (in the spirit of incompleteness à la Gödel)? I have lately started to think that undecidability, even in the strong sense (we cannot know versus we will not know), is a valid position to hold, since both of the classical cases seem to lead us to not knowing15. Even if we did know, it wouldn’t solve the problem. It may be that we just can’t know, and we have to accept it as it is. If such a position is accepted, the existence of God is simply not a meaningful question to pursue.

I’ve been thinking about this for a while, and I don’t know if being an agnostic is enough at this point. We should at some meta level discuss the question itself: whether it makes sense, and whether we would be willing to accept that it’s undecidable, or if a believable proof of undecidability could be constructed. Without a proof, choosing undecidability is in itself a belief. Unlike in mathematics, where you can choose the axioms and prove that a result is undecidable, you probably cannot do that with our existence. The belief of undecidability could again lead to similar problems as given above, but let me save you from additional mumbo-jumbo and leave you with what we have here.


  1. Z. Xu et al., “A generative AI-discovered TNIK inhibitor for idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis: a randomized phase 2a trial”, Nature Medicine 31, 2602–2610 (2025), doi:10.1038/s41591-025-03743-2; S. H. King et al., “Generative design of bacteriophages with genome language models”, Science 393, eaec2657 (2026), doi:10.1126/science.aec2657. ↩︎

  2. S. Dorkenwald et al., “Neuronal wiring diagram of an adult brain”, Nature 634, 124–138 (2024), doi:10.1038/s41586-024-07558-y. ↩︎

  3. P. K. Shiu et al., “A Drosophila computational brain model reveals sensorimotor processing”, Nature 634, 210–219 (2024), doi:10.1038/s41586-024-07763-9. ↩︎

  4. M. Januszewski and V. Jain (Google Research), blog post on the male fruit fly central nervous system map, MaleCNS v1.0 (3 September 2026), https://blog.google/innovation-and-ai/technology/research/male-fruit-fly-brain-map/. ↩︎

  5. B. Ferreira, “A Digital Fly Brain Has Taken Over the Internet”, 404 Media (15 September 2026), https://www.404media.co/a-digital-fly-brain-has-taken-over-the-internet/; nftechie, “Stonkfly”, GitHub, https://github.com/nftechie/stonkfly; Google AI (@GoogleAI), post on X, https://x.com/GoogleAI/status/2098109357624095155. ↩︎

  6. legendarylolo318-cloud, “Kick the Fly”, GitHub, https://github.com/legendarylolo318-cloud/kick-the-fly; RootVandal, “Subject 783”, GitHub, https://github.com/RootVandal/subject-783. ↩︎

  7. Odyssey (@odysseyml), post on X (17 October 2026), https://x.com/odysseyml/status/2111589148146749616. ↩︎

  8. N. Bostrom, “Are We Living in a Computer Simulation?”, Philosophical Quarterly 53, 243–255 (2003), doi:10.1111/1467-9213.00309. ↩︎

  9. I consider myself agnostic. I had a very basic religious upbringing, like most people. Then I was an atheist for a few years, after which I realized I’m more of an agnostic, which I’ve been now for quite some time. As an agnostic I believe that none of the classical gods, the Christian God or any of the nature gods, really exist. Of course, I don’t have any strong evidence against them, and I’m willing to give their existence a chance, a very slim chance for that matter, but a non-zero one. If I had to believe in a God, I would rather believe in a creator who didn’t create us, but created the universe, in a sense a kind of creator simulation theory assumes. In general, I don’t actively believe in any of this, but I also don’t actively deny any of it. ↩︎

  10. D. Hume, Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion (1779), Project Gutenberg, https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/4583. ↩︎

  11. I feel, also based on personal experience, that the usual “disproving” of classical religions by atheists and the like is more of a social counterreaction to the heavy-handed dogmatism perpetrated historically by classical religions, not a serious argument trying to disprove the existence of any God. ↩︎

  12. “Minecraftception”, Minecraft.net, https://www.minecraft.net/en-us/article/-minecraftception. ↩︎

  13. G. W. Leibniz, The Principles of Nature and Grace, Based on Reason (1714), §7. ↩︎

  14. E. P. Tryon, “Is the Universe a Vacuum Fluctuation?”, Nature 246, 396–397 (1973), doi:10.1038/246396a0. ↩︎

  15. I. Kant, Critique of Pure Reason (1781/1787), transl. J. M. D. Meiklejohn, Project Gutenberg, https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/4280. ↩︎

Comments

Comments run on GitHub Discussions, so you need a GitHub account to post.